An often fiery government critic, Egyptian journalist Khaled al-Balshi has been arrested, had his operations monitored and staff harassed by police for years. Yet his website Al-Bedaiah, a rare dissident voice in Egypt, was never touched.
That changed on Sunday when it suddenly went blank with no warning after being blocked, part of what Balshi called an unprecedented and far-reaching state crackdown on scores of news websites in recent weeks.
“Let’s be clear, the Egyptian websites going through this are dealing with a long-term shutdown — this is not short term,” said Balshi from his Cairo office, where four work stations sat idle, because staff feared coming to work in case of arrest.
Balshi’s website was the 57th blocked since May 24, according to the Association for Freedom of Thought and Expression, a non-government organisation tracking affected sites through software that monitors outages.
Journalists see the campaign against them as a step toward banning all but the most state-aligned media, effectively reversing the private media boom that flourished in the final decade of former president Hosni Mubarak’s rule and which they say helped push him from power in 2011.
Though no precise figures on readership are available, Egypt enjoys an active private media including widely read print and web format publications as well as popular late-night talk shows. State newspapers still maintain wide circulation.
The spike in censorship has come as a surprise, even to journalists long accustomed to reporting within strict red lines in Egypt where direct criticism of the military, the president and judiciary are considered taboo and punishable by jail time.
Government has offered no comment on the reason behind the blockages and the Ministry of Communication and Information Technology had no immediate comment.
Makram Mohamed Ahmed, head of the newly formed Supreme Media Council, a state media regulator, told Reuters he believes “the main reason is how much these websites deal with the Muslim Brotherhood or express support for terrorism,” referring to the Islamist group whose president Mohamed Mursi held office for a year before being ousted in 2013 by the military after mass protests.
The blockages have also hit Mada Masr, a self-described progressive outlet with no Islamist ties, as well as the widely read Al-Borsa, a financial newspaper favoured by the largely pro-government business community.
“If they did something more grave like arresting team members or me it would make big noise, whereas blocking the website is the best way to paralyse us without paying a high price for it,” Lina Atallah, editor of Mada Masr, told Reuters.
Some journalists say a presidential election in 2018 means Egypt is doubling down on press restrictions, a move intended to ensure opposition candidates have few spaces to challenge general-turned-president Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, who is widely expected to run for a second term.
“There are people getting ready to nominate themselves for the presidency and they have to make their voices heard or else they won’t be competitive,” said Adel Sabry, editor-in-chief of Masr al-Arabia, a website blocked last month.
“The goal is that it’s just one voice,” said editor-in-chief of Al-Borsa, Hussein Abd Rabo, adding his paper could be closed any day.
RED SEA ISLANDS
When Balshi’s website was wiped from Egyptian screens seven of its eight most read articles dealt with the same hot-button issue: a controversial accord transferring two Red Sea islands to Egypt’s top benefactor, Saudi Arabia. The measure is expected to be voted on within days by parliament.
Like another website blocked on Sunday, El Badil, Balshi’s has provided a platform for critics of the deal who argue the islands are Egyptian territory, a point of view that sparked rare street protests last year calling for the accord’s cancellation.
Balshi and other journalists believe the wave of censorship is meant to neutralise debate on an issue opposition figures say has already eroded some of Sisi’s support among voters who consider ceding sovereign territory unacceptable.
“I insist that we remain a voice, no matter what. And that we try to preserve our space. I think it should be done even as a suicide mission,” said Balshi. “What can we do?”