Migrants in limbo as deportation deal remains unfinished


Israel is finalising a deal to deport thousands of African migrants to Uganda under a new scheme after agreements with Rwanda and the UN’s refugee agency to find homes for those expelled fell through.

About 4,000 migrants left Israel for Rwanda and Uganda since 2013 under a voluntary programme but Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is under pressure from his right-wing voter base to expel thousands more.

In January, Israel started handing out notices to male migrants from Eritrea and Sudan giving them three months to take the voluntary deal with a plane ticket and $3,500 or risk being thrown in jail.

From April government would start forced deportations but rights groups challenged the move and Israel’s Supreme Court issued a temporary injunction to give petitioners more time to argue against the plan.

Government representatives told court on Tuesday an envoy was in an African country finalising a deportation deal after an arrangement with Rwanda to take migrants expelled under the new measures fell through.

The representatives did not name the country in court sessions open to the public though Israeli lawmakers previously said the countries it was planning to deport migrants to are Rwanda and Uganda.

Israeli Deputy Foreign minister Tzipi Hotovely identified the countries it was seeking to strike new deportation deals with as Uganda and Rwanda in closed-door comments leaked to Israeli Army Radio.

After the Rwanda deal fell through, government struck an agreement with the UNHCR to relocate 16,250 migrants to Western countries but Netanyahu scrapped it after an outcry from right-wing politicians furious thousands more would be allowed to stay in Israel.

The fate of tens of thousands of migrants who entered Israel illegally through its desert border with Egypt and were granted temporary visas has posed a moral dilemma for a state founded as a national home for Jews and a haven from persecution.

Israeli rights groups say the country can absorb the estimated 37,000 migrants still there, or should find them safe destinations such as those agreed under the defunct UNHCR deal.

Rights groups accuse Netanyahu, under police investigation for corruption, of playing political games to appeal to his right-wing supporters.

Government calls the migrants “infiltrators” and says they have come to find work. Migrants and rights groups say they are asylum seekers fleeing persecution.


The UN refugee agency and rights groups are also concerned because many Africans who left previously for Rwanda and Uganda voluntarily did not get protection promised and some ended up back on the migration trail.

Both countries denied any deals with Israel to resettle migrants. Uganda, a key Western ally in the fight against Islamist militants in East Africa, denied discussions about accepting deportees under the new scheme.
“We are not aware of any Israeli envoy here. Let Israelis tell you who that envoy here is going to sign an agreement with, sign with who? With foreign affairs, with the president, minister of internal affairs, with who? On what date are they signing?” Okello Oryem, Uganda’s junior foreign affairs minister told Reuters.

At the Supreme Court hearing in Jerusalem, one of three judges asked the state representatives why Uganda was denying the deal, if indeed there was one. The state said it would provide an explanation in a closed session.

Five migrants interviewed by Reuters said they were told by immigration officials they could go either to Uganda or Rwanda, if they chose to avoid detention.

Ristom Haliesilase, an Eritrean migrant living in Tel Aviv, was given until April 15 to decide whether to be deported, or detained.
“My mind is full of worries. I don’t know what will happen tomorrow. The first thought I have in the morning is what will they do to me today?” said Haliesilase. “It’s heart-breaking. It breaks the people. It breaks the community.”

Many migrants live in cramped apartments in poor parts of Tel Aviv where eateries serve Eritrean food, clothing stores with signs in Tigrinya display traditional garb and abandoned warehouses are converted into makeshift churches.

Rights groups including the International Refugee Rights Initiative are documenting the plight of Eritrean and Sudanese men who have left Israel for Rwanda and Uganda for several years.

In the past few months UNHCR has also documented at least 80 cases of Eritreans who found none of the protection promised on their departure from Israel, prompting them to go through conflict zones to reach Europe.

Along the way they were subjected to arrest, torture and extortion before trying to cross the Mediterranean to reach Italy, UNHCR said. Israeli rights groups have documented dozens more such cases.

Under the voluntary scheme, asylum seekers were given the option of going back to their country of origin, remaining in detention in Israel or flying to a third country where they were promised they could stay and work legally.

Sajir (27) an Eritrean now living in Uganda, told Reuters he flew there in January after spending five months in Israeli detention.
“They said that my life would be sorted there,” Sajir said, speaking in Hebrew. “But it’s all a scam.”

Notices handed out to migrants already in detention or those trying to renew visas have promised residency and work permits in their destination country. “A local team will meet you at the airport and provide guidance in the first few days,” the document says.

Sajir said when his flight landed in Uganda, he and 10 other migrants did not go through passport control. “We were taken out the back. Then someone loaded us onto a bus and took us to a hotel,” he said.

The group was met by a man who offered to set them up with traffickers to take them to Sudan, Kenya or Ethiopia – for a price, he said.
“We got no visa, no papers. There is no work here. It is no good. I cannot stay here. I will try to go to Sudan soon or somewhere, to Libya and then to Europe,” Sajir said.

Israel’s Immigration Authority and the prime minister’s office did not respond to requests for comment.