When Libya’s coastguard received the first of a long-awaited batch of patrol boats from Italy last month, two of the four had mechanical problems and one broke down in transit to Tripoli.
As Italy’s interior minister later flew in to officially present the boats at a naval base in the Libyan capital, coast guards grumbled the vessels were old and had little deck space for rescued migrants.
“They want us to be Europe’s policeman. At the same time, that policeman needs resources,” said naval coastguard spokesman Ayoub Qassem. “I challenge anyone to work in these conditions.”
Half a million people crossed the Mediterranean from Libya to Italy over the past four years, mainly sub-Saharan Africans who pay smugglers to shepherd them across the desert to Libya and onward to Europe in unseaworthy dinghies. An estimated 13,000 have drowned.
European governments want to stop migrants and break the grip of smugglers. But more than four months after Italy and the European Union launched a new push to tackle the crisis, accounts by migrants, aid workers and officials show that effort is failing to make a difference.
When Libyan authorities do catch migrants, they take them to detention centres nominally under government control, which already house about 8,000 people. Europeans have pledged funding to improve the camps, some are still so cramped migrants have to sleep sitting up.
At Tripoli’s Tariq al-Siqqa migrant centre, where visiting dignitaries are brought, flowers have been planted and wash-basins installed. But behind a padlocked metal gate hundreds of migrants languish, crammed side to side on mattresses in a single unventilated room.
“They shut us up, they imprison us, they ask us for money,” said a 22-year-old from Guinea, who has been in the centre since March, when he was intercepted by the Libyan coastguard with about 120 other migrants shortly after they set off for Italy. “They hit people. They don’t like black skin.”
NO TURKEY DEAL IN NORTH AFRICA
The sea route from the Libyan coast is one of two main routes in the biggest flow of migrants to Europe since World War Two. The other, by sea from Turkey to Greece, was largely shut down last year after an agreement between the EU and Ankara, but the flow from Libya has increased.
This year has seen 70,000 people make the journey, with the summer peak season for the voyage just beginning. An estimated 2,000 died to date this year.
Unlike Turkey, Libya is still seen as too dangerous for Europeans to send migrants back, so those who make it into international waters usually end up in Italy.
Libya’s people-smuggling networks flourished amid the upheaval following the revolution that toppled dictator Muammar al-Gaddafi in 2011 and their trade surged after 2014, when conflict spread and rival governments were set up in Tripoli and the east.
Since last year, the EU has made a push to co-operate with a new Libyan government backed by the United Nations. Coastguard training began on board EU ships in October. In February, Italy signed a memorandum of understanding with Tripoli the EU quickly endorsed, earmarking 90 million euros.
But Europe has delivered little concrete support, said Tarek Shanbour, a senior coastguard official. “We meet, we talk, we take decisions, we make agreements, but on the ground there is no execution.”
The Libyan government has little sway outside the capital or even over some ministries within it. Its authority has been rejected in the east and is barely felt in the south where smugglers bring migrants in across the Sahara.
“So far we can’t say as the European Union we’ve achieved much,” a European official said on condition of anonymity. “The point is we need short term solutions but there are no short term solutions. There is no Turkey deal in North Africa.”
As European policy makers study longer-term schemes to improve security on Libya’s southern borders, wean communities off smuggling, and provide aid in migrants’ countries of origin, Libyan officials worry numbers inside Libya will swell.
They say they have little capacity to host migrants in a country deep in economic crisis, where nearly 250,000 are still internally displaced.
European funding has helped increase voluntary repatriations of migrants caught in Libya who agree to return home, but this is unlikely to surpass 10,000 this year.
Migrants caught by the Libyan coastguard at sea or swept up in night raids are detained in migrant centres, both official ones nominally run by government and others by an array of armed groups.
Those running the centres raise money by making migrants or their families pay for their release, selling them back to smugglers or hiring them out for labour, migrants say. Sexual abuse is common, according to a former staff member at one of the Tripoli centres.
In unofficial centres and holding houses in western and southern Libya, run by militias or even smugglers, conditions are said to be worse. Migrants say video or audio of them being tortured is relayed to their families to extort cash transfer payments.
Migrants at Tariq Siqqa who were previously held at another, half-built camp near Tripoli’s Mitiga airport said they were forced to build the centre themselves. Several died from untreated illnesses. A Reuters request to visit the centre was declined.
Detention centre staff said they lack resources and sometimes have to use force with desperate or unruly migrants.
Mohamed Bishr, head of Tripoli’s Department of Combating Illegal Migration (DCIM), dismissed reports of abuse and killings, saying migrants were detained for their own protection.
“Given the security situation inside the Libyan state they cannot leave the detention centres because they do not have identification documents,” he said, speaking in a roomy, air conditioned office inside the Tariq Siqqa centre. “They might face the worst if they leave.”