Distrust makes Sudan talks impossible


Outside mediation is needed to defuse Sudan’s crisis because the ruling military council and opposition distrust each other too deeply for direct talks following a deadly raid on a protest camp according to the top US diplomat for Africa.

US Assistant Secretary of State for Africa Tibor Nagy met victims of the June 3 raid during a visit to Khartoum and he described their accounts as “harrowing”.

The raid, in which opposition-linked doctors say more than 100 people were killed, led to the collapse of stalled talks over a political transition towards elections and civilian rule following the overthrow of autocrat Omar al-Bashir in April.

The military ousted and arrested Bashir after 16 weeks of protests, setting up a transitional council and entering talks with an alliance of protest and opposition groups that stalled over who would lead a three-year transition.

Nagy, speaking from Addis Ababa, said Washington’s newly named envoy to Sudan, veteran diplomat Donald Booth, would focus on supporting mediation efforts led by the African Union and IGAD, an African trade bloc.

“Why mediation – why not direction negotiation between parties? The parties absolutely do not trust each other in any way,” Nagy said.

While in Khartoum, Nagy met opposition groups and civil society and military council head Lieutenant General Abdel Fattah al-Burhan.


The conversation with Burhan “was about as frank and direct as possible. It was quite an exchange of views and obviously we did not agree on some key points,” Nagy said.

“From our point of view we mentioned events of June 3 constituted a 180 degree turn in the way events were going, with murder, rape and pillaging by security forces.”

Washington believes there has to be an investigation into the incident that is “independent and credible”, he said.

“We spoke to some victims including an American citizen who was shot and those accounts were harrowing and persuasive.”

The Sudanese government confirmed 61 deaths in the sit-in raid.

Shams El Din Kabbashi, the military council spokesman, said there were excesses and deviations from a plan devised after the council ordered military leaders to clear the sit-in.

Some officers were arrested in connection with the raid and results of an investigation will be announced, he said.

Stability in Sudan, which has been grappling with an economic crisis, is crucial for a volatile region struggling with conflict and insurgencies from the Horn of Africa to Egypt and Libya.

Wealthy Gulf states are among the foreign powers trying to influence the path of the nation of 40 million.

The United States imposed sanctions on Sudan under Bashir which were largely lifted in 2017. Sudan remains on the US list of state sponsors of terrorism, preventing it from accessing funding from international lenders.