Liberia’s Supreme Court halted preparations for next week’s presidential run-off vote between former soccer star George Weah and Vice President Joseph Boakai until it considers a challenge to first round results by a losing candidate who alleged fraud.
The decision casts further doubt on the October 10 poll losing parties say was marred by foul play at polling stations and at the highest levels of government.
It could also delay a second-round vote scheduled for November 7 to find a successor to President Ellen Johnson Sirleaf, who won a Nobel Peace Prize in 2011 and is the country’s first elected leader since a 14-year civil war ended in 2003.
In a writ issued on Tuesday, the court instructed the Liberty Party of third-placed Charles Brumskine, the complainant, and the National Elections Commission, to file briefs by Thursday.
“This is a big step in the right direction,” said Liberty Party Chairman Benjamin Sanvee. “The Court recognises the gravity of the issues and has taken action in defence of the law and democracy.”
This week, Boakai’s ruling Unity Party announced it was backing the legal challenge. It accused Johnson Sirleaf, one of its own members, of interfering in the October vote by holding private meetings with election magistrates.
Johnson Sirleaf denied the meetings were inappropriate. Observers from the European Union and the Carter Centre say they saw no major problems with the first round vote.
The Supreme Court’s decision is an example of an increasingly assertive role some African judiciaries are playing in overseeing elections. Kenya’s Supreme Court annulled the results of a presidential election in August.
National Elections Commission chairman Jerome Korkoya questioned the need for the Supreme Court’s decision, which he said halted preparations for the vote, including training polling station staff.
“Let me categorically say I see no reason, legal or otherwise, for such an order,” he told reporters. “The election was transparent and credible.”
Looking to head off a crisis, the chairman of West African regional body ECOWAS, Togolese President Faure Gnassingbe, and the African Union chair, Guinea’s president Alpha Conde, arrived in Monrovia on Wednesday.
“There have been some complaints, some challenges. That process is ongoing in keeping with the rule of law,” Johnson Sirleaf said at a news conference alongside Gnassingbe, Conde, Weah, Boakai and three other candidates.
“This democratic process must be concluded within the time frame of the constitution so that I may be able to retire and end this transition successfully,” she said.
The streets of Monrovia remained calm though the court ruling raised tension in the capital where memories of the war are fresh. Large numbers of riot police deployed outside the Supreme Court and election commission headquarters.
“I see this entire process as critical to our survival as a nation. We must do all to avoid sliding into war,” said student David Farmah. “No one has money to have a re-run of the election. It should go ahead.”
Weah won the first round with 38.4% of the vote to Boakai’s 28.8%. He tapped into frustration with Johnson Sirleaf’s 12-year tenure, which saw post-war peace consolidated and the economy quadruple in size but failed to root out corruption and alleviate poverty.
Morluba Morlu, a senior official from Weah’s CDC party, said he still expected the run-off to go ahead next week.
“It is sad for a ruling party that has been in power for 12 years to be crying,” he said of Unity Party’s support for the legal challenge. “We don’t want any mockery of this election.”