BAE Systems bribery suit may be taken to US Supreme Court
Written by Reuters, Monday, 04 January 2010
A US appeals court ruled this week against the fund for employees of the city of Harper Woods, Michigan. The court said English law, not US law, governed the shareholder lawsuit over alleged bribes to Saudi Prince Bandar bin Sultan and others.
The appeals court, which upheld a lower court's finding, left the fund to pursue its case in Britain, Reuters reports.
Patrick Coughlin, the plaintiffs' lead attorney, said the fund had no plans to take its case to England.
Instead, he said it may appeal to the high court against the dismissal of the case on Tuesday by the US Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia.
"Will consider" going to the Supreme Court, Coughlin, of Coughlin, Stoia, Geller, Rudman, Robbins LLP, said in a terse email reply to Reuters. "No current plans to litigate in England."
He did not respond to questions about why he did not plan to take the case to England. The original suit was brought in September 2007.
The pension fund has charged that current and former directors and executives of BAE, Britain's No. 1 arms maker, breached their fiduciary duties and wasted corporate assets by allegedly allowing illegal bribes and kickbacks in the 1980s arm deal known as al-Yamamah, or "the Dove."
BAE has denied that wrongful payments were made to secure the deal in which Tornado fighter jets, Hawker trainer aircraft and other military hardware were sold to Saudi Arabia in exchange for oil starting in 1985. The value of the government-to-government barter has been estimated at up to $80 billion, Britain's costliest arms deal.
BAE welcomed the US appeals court ruling, said Lindsay Walls, a company spokeswoman in London.
Lawyers for Bandar, a former ambassador to the United States, have denied any wrongdoing on his part.
The plaintiffs had argued the United States should have jurisdiction because more than $2 billion in alleged bribes went to Bandar through an account at Riggs Bank, a defunct Washington DC financial institution.
BAE defendants countered that nearly all of them reside outside the United States, and none in Washington DC.
Britain's Serious Fraud Office in December 2006 dropped an inquiry into the al-Yamamah deal. Then-Prime Minister Tony Blair said pursuing the matter threatened national security and ties with Saudi Arabia, which he called crucial for counter-terrorism efforts and Middle East peace.
In June 2007, BAE said the US Justice Department had opened its own investigation of BAE's compliance with anti-bribery laws, including dealings with Saudi Arabia. The department did not respond to a request for comment on its investigation.
- Egypt, Saudis seek united front against militant Islam
- BAE Land Systems SA to be sold to Denel
- BAE Systems unveils new RG35 variant
- Muslim Brotherhood urges Britain not to yield to foreign 'pressure' over review
- South Arabia sentences 13 for backing militants in kingdom and abroad
- UK defence industry has high hopes for unmanned aircraft Taranis
- Saudi Arabia to jail citizens who fight abroad
- Iraq militia says fires mortar bombs at Saudi as warning
- Three Eritrean officers defect to Saudi Arabia
- African workers in Riyadh seek repatriation after two riot deaths
South African launch: INTENS Image Intensifier tube, 4G Night Vision standard
by ECM Technologies, 21 August 2014
Developed by PHOTONIS, the tube is a multi-mission night vision tool, and will be unveiled at Africa Aerospace and Defence in September.
US-Africa Summit 2014: Africa on the agenda or too little too late?
by Paramount Group, 20 August 2014
A revitalised viewpoint on Africa, and its challenges and opportunities for investors, should take centre stage at US-Africa Summit 2014, says Paramount Group.
Airbus Defence and Space improves air surveillance capabilities of Indonesian Air Force
by AIRBUS Defence & Space, 19 August 2014
The company has provided the Indonesian Air Force with the latest aircraft identification and air surveillance equipment.
Sustained revenue growth, strong order book drive Denel's new growth era
by Denel Corporate, 18 August 2014
The company's financial results show revenue growth of 17%, improved profit and the largest multi-year order book in its history.
Atlantis Aviation offers air-land integration, close air support, airborne ISTAR training to Africa
by Atlantis Corporation, 14 August 2014
Close Air Solutions is a single source for international training services in all aspects of close air support.
Reutech Group to exhibit at Africa Aerospace 2014
by Reutech, 14 August 2014
Products on display at the show will include Reutech's new Tactical Communications network suite and the Ngada border surveillance radar.