Armed guards on commercial ships a risky business - expert
Speaking at the Maritime and Coastal Security Africa 2012 conference held in Cape Town last week, he said that despite the recent decline in piracy statistics, piracy off the Horn of Africa is not going away.
Marriott-Watson attributes much of the decline to the proliferation of embarked armed vessel protection teams and the 27-nation Combined Maritime Forces (CMF) applying immense pressure off the Somali coastline and thereby disrupting Pirate Action Groups (PAGs). A PAG typically comprises a mother ship and three to five skiffs which swarm the victim vessel.
However, Marriott-Watson attributes one of the prime causes of the reduction in pirate activity to the Kenyan military forces that recently seized the Somalia port city of Kismayo from al Qaeda-linked al-Shabab militants. He also believes that there is a significant under reporting of pirate attacks.
The largest risk associated with using Privately Contracted Armed Security Personnel (PCASP) and maritime security companies is the cost and complexity of operating legal weapons in accordance with codes of conduct. This particularly relates to the use of End User Certificates (EUC).
The use of legal weapons aboard commercial vessels incurs highs costs associated with obtaining the EUC, transportation and safe storage of the weapons. The PCASP must ensure that the weapons and associated EUC are controlled prior to embarkation and again prior to arriving in a foreign port. Clearances and import permits must be obtained, the weapons safeguarded and transported back to the home country.
A further complication is the ease of utilising JV (joint-venture) weapons, whereby weapons are shared amongst many users and PCASP.
One way to alleviate this logistical nightmare is to use floating armouries, something a large number of security providers rely on. In April this year, then South African Minister of Defence and Military Veterans, Lindiwe Sisulu, said that a number of European countries had approached South Africa with the request that South Africa assist the armed guards that provide anti-piracy protection aboard merchant ships. This included South Africa facilitating the establishment of an offshore floating armoury. Sisulu noted that South Africa was still grabbling with this issue, particularly the legality and ethics involved.
In terms of the International Maritime Organization’s regulations, commercial vessels are generally not allowed to have armed guards at sea. Consequently this “could draw the Company Security Officer, directors, and management into difficulties.”
He further warned of the dangers posed by inexperienced, ill-disciplined PCASP and maritime security, with the client having little or no control over who the company employs.
There are ways, however, to mitigate the risk associated with weapons liability. This includes the vessel owner/operator demanding to see that the licenses, EUC and liability cover are all in same company name, conducting due diligence on the PMSC prior to engagement and to conduct audits regularly to safeguard against commercial shortcuts.
Piracy is not going away and with the stretching of naval forces, Privately Contracted Armed Security Personnel will continue to be embarked on commercial vessels transiting areas of known pirate activity.
“The one statistic which is irrefutable,” Marriott-Watson says, “is that no ship that has been armed has been taken.”
Top stories this week
- Soldiers involved in Port Elizabeth eviction showed “contempt” for the rule of law
- US hands over six Hueys to Kenya – two more on the way
- Shrinking defence budget has affected Armscor and forced change – retirees
- New JOps deputy chief named, but no word on a new Chief
- Low-tech proves effective for KZN/Mozambique border protection
- Somali forces kill three in attack on IS-linked fighters
- UN identifies 41 Burundi, Gabon troops accused of abuse in CAR
- ISS: Where to from here for the UN in South Sudan?
- Seven dead in Somali/IS clash
- Ethnic cleansing underway in South Sudan: UN Commission
- ISS: Africa pushes for a 2017 ban on nuclear weapons
- US battling for votes to secure South Sudan arms embargo
- Insurgents behead Somali village elders over Islamic tax
- Bomb kills four Somali soldiers as forces mull attack on Islamic State
- Canada extends UN South Sudan deployment
Denel joins forces with global leaders to market geospatial products
by Denel Corporate, 6 December 2016
Denel Integrated Systems and Maritime will team up with Hexagon Geospatial and Geo Data Design to market geospatial products.
Saab receives order for Carl-Gustaf M4
by Saab, 6 December 2016
This is Saab's fourth customer for the system since its launch in late 2014.
Umkhonto missile ready for final testing on frigates
by Denel Corporate, 1 December 2016
Delivery of Denel's Umkhonto surface-to-air missile to an international client has reached an advanced stage, with testing scheduled for early 2017.